Sunday, November 22, 2026

Samaysar 12

 

Gatha 87: The Mithyatva which has been told earlier, is of two types- one is Jiva-Mithyatva and other Ajiva-Mithyatva; in the same way Agyan, Avirati, Yog,  Moha and anger etc. Kashaya, all these bhavas have two types i.e. Jiva and Ajiva. 

Commentary: Mithya Darshan, Agyan and Avirati etc. bhavas are felt by both Ajiva and Jiva  like peacock and mirror, hence they are Ajiva as well as Jiva. This is explained with illustration- Just as blue, green, yellow etc. colour form bhava which are present in the peacock by nature is peacock only; and the one seen in the mirror as image form  having blue, green,  yellow etc. bhavas is present due to cleanliness of the mirror, and it is mirror only. In the same way the Mithya Darshan, Agyan, Avirati etc. bhava which are felt by ajiva due to its Dravya swabhava are ajiva only and the Mithya Darshan, Agyan, Avirati, etc. bhavas felt by Jiva due to corruption of Chaitanya are jiva only.

Bhavartha: The paramanu of pudgala manifest in pudgala Mithyatva etc. karma form. With fructification of that karma the taste of Mithyatva etc. which   is generated, that is Mithyatva Ajiva and with the nimitta of karma the jiva manifests in vibhava form, those vibhava manifestations are corruption of Chetan hence they are jiva. Here it should be understood that the Prakritis of Mithatva etc. karmas are paramanu of pudgala Dravya. Jiva is Upayoga form. His upayoga has such cleanliness that with fruition of pudgala karma, in accordance with the taste of its fruition the upayoga manifests in such shape form.  Agyani due to agyan does not have bheda gyan of its taste and Upayoga, hence he considers the taste itself to be his own bhava. When bheda Gyan is there i.e. the Jiva knows the jiva bhava as jiva and ajiva bhava as ajiva, then Mithyatva becomes absent and Samyak Gyan is attained.

Tatparya Vritti Commentary: Now Atma carries out  the Chaitanya form Atma Bhavas, in the same way the pudgala carries out the achetan form corporeal Dravya karma etc. other bhavas, this is told-

Mithyatva is of two kinds- Jiva Swabhva and Ajiva Swabhava. In the same way the Agyan, Avirati, Yog, Moha, Anger etc. bhavas also are Jiva and Ajiva form ( of two types each) like peacock and the image of peacock in mirror. They are as follows-

Just as the blue, yellow etc. specific shapes which  are manifested in the form of shape of peacock body, they are peacock, Chetan form only. In the same way the sukh-dukh etc.  form vikalpa bhavas experienced by the jiva fallen from pure Atmanubhuti, from aspect of Ashuddha Nishchaya naya are Chetana form only. And just as the reflection of face etc. form corruption bhava reflected due to cleanliness of mirror are achetan only, in the same way the Gyanavarana etc. Dravya karma form paryayas caused by pudgala Dravya suitable for karma vargana in Upadan form  are pudgala only, achetan only.

Now the question arises that Mithyatva etc. have been called as Jiva and Ajiva, then who are the Jiva Mithyatva etc. and Ajiva Mithyatva  etc. This is replied-

Gatha 88: The Mithyatva, Yog, Avirati and Agyan Ajiva are pudgala karmas while Agyan, Avirati, and Mithyatva Jiva is Upayoga.

Commentary: From aspect of Nishchaya the Mithya darshan, Agyan, Avirati etc. Ajiva are different from non  corporeal Chaitanya manifestations and are corporeal Pudgala karma. While the Mithya Darshan, Agyan,  Avirati etc. jiva are corruptions of Chaitanya manifestations different from corporeal pudgala karma.

Tatparya Vritti Commentary: Now  how many types of Jiva and Ajiva are there? Upon asking, it is replied as follows-

Pudgala karma form Mithyatva, Yog, Avirati, Agyan are Ajiva. The Upayoga form  bhava which is corrupted manifestation  of knowing the shuddhatma tattva bhava in converse form is Agyan of Jiva. The corrupted manifestation of Non-Vrita converse to the uncorrupted Swanubhuti  is  Avirati of Jiva. The converse shraddhan  in the subject of Shuddha jiva etc. Padartha with converse intent form Upayoga is Mithyatva which is Jiva. What is the meaning of Jiva? These Agyan, Avirati and Mithyatva  Jiva form are Bhava Pratyaya ( elements) – this is the meaning.

Now again question arises that when did the corruption of Chaitanya manifestation  in the form of Mithya Darshan etc. occur? That is replied here-

Gatha 89: Being associated with Moha eternally, the Upayoga has three types of manifestations since beginningless times. These are Mithyatva, Agyan and Avirati Bhava.

Commentary: Although from aspect of Nishchaya naya, all substances have capability of manifesting in its natural form,  even then being conjoined with other substance form  Moha since beginningless times, the Upayoga of Atma manifests in corrupted forms of Mithya darshan, Agyan and Avirati. That corruption of manifestation of Upayoga is seen to appear due to affliction of others, just like the corruption of manifestation of Sapphire stone. The same is clarified- Just as the Sapphire stone, in spite of having  capability of manifesting in bright form, sometimes appears in corrupted forms of black, green, yellow etc. due to association with those colour forms support bases;  in the same way the Upayoga of Atma due to association with other substance form Moha which has nature of Mithya Darshan, Agyan and Avirati since eternal times, manifests in the corrupted forms of Mithya darshan, Agyan and avirati respectively.

Bhavartha: The three types of corrupted manifestations of Upayoga of Atma is due to nimitta of eternal karma. It  is not so that he was Shuddha earlier and later has become corrupted. If it were so then even Siddhas would have had corruption in manifestation, but it is not so. Hence it should be understood that it is eternal only.

Tatparya Vritti Commentary: How did the Mithya darshan etc. corruption get generated in the Jiva having nature of Shuddha Chaitanya, is told now-

Having Upayoga characteristics the Atma is Upayoga form. From aspect of eternal progeny it has three types of manifestations. Which type of three manifestations of Atma?  These three are conjoined with Moha. Which are these three? Mithyatva, Avirati and Agyan  are these three manifestations. Its detail- Although from  aspect of Shuddha Nishchaya naya the Jiva is shuddha Buddha by nature, even then due to eternal Mohaniya Karma bondage he has three types of corruptions in manifestations of the types of Mithyatva, Agyan and Avirati form. Here the Shuddha Jiva nature is venerable while Mithyatva etc. three corruptions of manifestations are despicable.

Now the authorship of the Atma of the three types of corrupted manifestations is described-

Gatha 90: Although the Upayoga of Atma since eternal times (from aspect of Shuddha naya) is Shuddha, pure, (one) bhava but on account of three types of corrupted manifestations, the corrupted bhava in which  the Upayoga engages in himself, he gets to be Karta of that Bhava.

Commentary: In this way since eternal times, on account of association with other substance form Moha, three types of corrupted manifestations of Mithya Darshan, Agyan and Avirati Bhava are generated within self and with their nimitta, although in reality the Upayoga is Shuddha, pure, one type having beginningless-endless Chaitanya bhava form, even then  attaining ashuddha, impure, several bhava-ness being of three kinds, himself being  Agyani, attaining authorship, manifesting in corrupted form, whichever bhava he treats as his own, he becomes Upayoga karta of those  bhavas. 

Bhavartha : Earlier it was told that the one who manifests is Karta. Here the Upayoga manifested in Agyan form hence the bhava form in which he manifested, he is called karta of that bhava. In this way the upayoga should be known as Karta. Although from  aspect of Shuddha dravyarthika naya, Atma is not  karta, even then with Upayoga and Atma being one thing, from aspect of Ashuddha Dravyarthika naya, the Atma is also called as Karta.

Tatparya Vritti Commentary: Now Atma has authorship of three types of Vibhava manifestations of Mithyatva etc., it  is told-

With the nimitta of  fruition of Mithya Darshan, Mithya Gyan, Mithya Charitra, the Upayoga form  Atma having characteristics of Gyanopayoga, Darshanopayoga manifests in three forms like the Sapphire stone afflicted with black, blue, yellow three types of afflictions. But in reality he is Shuddha free of raga etc. bhava karma. He is pure devoid of gyanavarana etc. Dravya karma form blemishes. And how is he? In spite of Bhava or Padartha being indivisible one illuminated Gyan natured, even then due to corrupted manifestations of Mithya Darshan-Gyan-Charitra forms as described earlier, being of three types, the manifestations of  that Atma  occur in corrupted form. The manifestations following Chaitanya are called as Upayoga which is characteristics of Atma. Deviating from uncorrupted  experience of gyan form manifestations, the Atma becomes karta of those Mithyatva etc. three types of manifestations, but he does not become karta of Dravya karma- this is the bhava.

Now it is told that when the Atma  is having authorship of three types of corrupted manifestations, then pudgala Dravya itself manifests in Karma form-

Gatha 91: The Bhava in which the Atma engages, he gets to be Karta of that Bhava; upon him  being karta, pudgala Dravya itself manifests in karma form.

Commentary: The bhava which is carried out by the Atma in reality by himself manifesting in that form, he is karta like the occultist practicing mantra. With the nimitta of that bhava of Atma, the pudgala Dravya itself manifests in karma form. The same thing is elaborated- Just as Sadhak manifesting that form of Dhyan Bhava himself is Karta of that Dhyan and that Dhyan Bhava being favourable as nimitta  for all the Sadhya Bhavas, without Sadhak being karta, the poison of snake on its own gets cured, the women themselves attain ironical conditions, the ties get broken on their own. In the same way this Atma, on account of Agyan, himself manifesting in MithyaDarshan etc. bhava forms gets to be karta of Mithya Darshan etc. bhavas. And that Mithya Darshan etc. bhavas being favourable as nimitta for Pudgala Dravya to manifest in karma form, without Atma being karta, the pudgala Dravya manifest in Mohaniya etc. karma form by itself.

Bhavartha : Atma manifests in Agyan  form, engaging in ownership with some, raga with some and dwesha with some; thus he himself gets to be karta of those bhavas. With the nimitta of those bhavas the pudgala Dravya itself manifests in karma form. Only mutual nimitta-naimittik relationship is there. Both are karta of their own bhavas- this is Nishchaya.

Tatparya Vritti commentary: Now upon  Atma being karta of  the three types of Mithyatva etc. corruptions of manifestations, the pudgala Dravya suitable for being karma vargana themselves  manifest in karma form being  Upadan. This is told-

The bhava or the Mithyatva etc. corrupted manifestation which is carried out by Atma deviating from Shuddha swabhava, Atma is karta of that Bhava. (Upon Atma) Being karta of those three types of corrupted manifestations, at that moment only pudgala Dravya suitable for being karma vargana themselves in Upadan form  manifest in Dravya karma form. How does it manifest? Just as with the manifestation of a Mantra-Tantra practitioner, in another country, without the activities of that practitioner, the poison in some other person’s body gets removed, shackles get broken, women attaining irony etc.  occur.  In the same way at the time of destruction of Mithyatva raga etc. vibhava bhava, with   the manifestations of the form of Nishchaya jewel trio form Shuddhopayoga“ like the person being cured of poison with the mantra”, being ineffective themselves the earlier bonded Dravya karma separating  from jiva attain Nirjara- this is the Bhavartha.

Now it is told that the karma is generated out of Agyan only-

Gatha 92:  The one who treats others in the form of self  and treats self also in the form of  others, that agyani jiva is karta of karmas.

Commentary: This Atma with Agyan without knowing difference between self and others, treating others as self and self as others, being agyan form himself appears as karta of karmas. This is elaborated- Just as the cold and hot states of pudgala manifestations capable of imparting experiences of cold and hot, being indifferent from pudgala is completely different from  Atma and the experience of that nature attained with its nimitta is indifferent from Atma hence is completely different from pudgala. In the same way the states of manifestations of pudgala of raga-dwesha, sukh-dukh etc. forms capable of providing such experience, being indifferent from pudgala are completely different from Atma and that kind of experience attained with its nimitta, being indifferent from Atma is completely different from pudgala. Due to Agyan the Atma does not realise the difference between raga-dwesha, sukh-dukh etc. and their experience. Therefore with false belief of oneness he manifests in hot-cold forms (which are not possible for Atma to manifest in). In the same way he manifests in raga-dwesha, sukh-dukh forms due to Agyan and revealing the Agyan nature he believes that ‘I am ragi, I am sukhi, I am  dukhi‘ etc. In this way he appears like karta of raga etc. karma.

Bhavartha : Raga-dwesha, sukh-dukh etc. states are tastes of fruition of pudgala karma; hence like  cold-hot it is indifferent from pudgala karma and totally different from Atma. Due to Agyan the Atma without having bheda gyan, he believes that this is my taste only. This is so since due to purity of gyan the tastes of raga-dwesha like that of cold and hot  are reflected in gyan and as if gyan only has become raga-dwesha form- thus it appears to the Agyani. Hence he believes that ‘I am ragi, I am  dweshi, I am angry, I am proud etc.’ In this way the Agyani jiva gets to be karta of raga-dwesha etc.

Tatparya Vritti commentary: Now from aspect of Nishchaya the lack of Veetrag gyan of own experience only is called Agyan. Hence with agyan only the karmas are generated, this is conveyed-

Atma due to lack of bhed-gyan of other Dravya and Atma believes the bhava karma-dravya karma form other Dravya to be Atma form.  And the one who believes Shuddhatma to be other form- such jiva is agyan form, he is karta of karmas. That is as follows: Just as some person experiences the hot and cold form pudgala manifestations of states as that of Atma due to practice of oneness without knowing the difference. Therefore he is karta of cold and hot states manifestation of Atma believing ‘ I am  hot, I am  cold’. In the same way the jiva also with the nimitta of pudgala manifestations different from the experience of Shuddha Atma manifests in sukh-dukh   form due to belief of oneness due to lack of gyan of own experience. Therefore he manifests as ‘I am sukhi, I am  dukhi’ etc. In this way he gets to be  karta of karmas- this is the Bhavartha.

Now it is told that the karma is not generated by Gyan-

Gatha 93: The one which does not transform others into own form nor does he  transform self into other’s form, such gyan form jiva is akarta of karmas i.e. he does not become karta.

Commentary: When this Atma knows the difference between self and others by means of  gyan then he does not transform others into own form nor does he transform  self into other’s form, being gyan form he appears  to be Akarta of karmas. The same is elaborated- Just as states of cold-hot of pudgala manifestations being indifferent from pudgala, capable of giving experience of cold-hot, is always totally different from Atma and the attained experience with its nimitta being indifferent from Atma  is always totally different from pudgala, in the same way the raga-dwesha, sukh-dukh form  states of pudgala manifestations, capable of giving experience of sukh-dukh etc., being indifferent from pudgala are always totally different from Atma while the experience of that kind attained with its nimitta is totally different from pudgala and indifferent from Atma. When by means of gyan the Atma knows the difference of raga-dwesha, sukh-dukh etc. and own experience, then they are not one but different, with such bheda gyan, like cold-hot forms which Atma cannot manifest into, not manifesting at all in such raga-dwesha, sukh-dukh etc. forms manifested by Agyani Atma,  revealing the gyan form of gyan, being Gyan himself, “ I only know the raga; raga is pudgala’ with such technique he appears as Akarta of raga etc. karma which is converse to gyan.

Bhavartha: When the Atma knows the states of raga-dwesha, sukh -dukh  etc. as different from Gyan i.e. “ Just as states of pudgala are hot and cold, in the same way the states of pudgala are raga-dwesha etc.” , with such bheda gyan he knows self as knower only and knows raga etc. form pudgala. Upon this, Atma does not remain karta of raga etc.  but remains  Gyata only.

Tatparya Vritti Commentary: Now with Veetrag gyan of own  experience the karma does not get generated, this is told-

The one who does not treat other Dravya- body etc. external subjects no-karma form, bhava karma form, internal raga etc. and Dravya karma form other dravyas as Atma form with the power of bheda gyan, does not relate them to Atma; then such pure experience characteristics form bheda vigyani jiva not treating Shuddha Dravya-guna-paryaya natured own Atma as others form becomes Akarta of Karmas.

Its detail- Just as some person having bheda gyan of cold-hot states of pudgala manifestations and the same kind of experience of cold-hot states of Atma, does not become Karta of ‘I am cold, I am hot’ such manifestations; in the same way the jiva also knowing the states of pudgala manifestations different from Shuddha Atmanubhuti and the experience of sukh-dukh with the nimitta of those states and the difference of experience of sukh generated by own Shuddha atmanubhuti, with the practice of bheda gyan, not manifesting in raga-dwesha-moha manifestations  remains akrata of karmas. Hence it establishes that gyan does not generate karmas.

Now the question arises how karma is generated with agyan? That is answered-

Gatha 94: The three kinds of Upayoga engages in vikalpa of ‘I am angry’; then that Atma gets to be karta of that Upayoga form bhava.

Commentary: In reality in Samanya agyan  form Mithya Darshan-Agyan-Avirati forms three types of corrupted Chaitanya manifestations are there. Due to lack of darshan between self and others, with lack of gyan and lack  of concentration without knowing the difference, the Chetan and Achetan  manifest as Bhavya-Bhavak forms and experience self as ‘I am anger’, thus  such vikalpa is generated. Therefore ‘ I am anger’ with such delusion manifesting in such corrupted manifestation form that Atma gets to be karta of such corrupted manifestations form bhava. In the same way in place of anger, pride, deceit, greed, moha, raga, dwesha, karma, nokarma, mind, speech, body , ears, eyes, nose, taste, and touch form sixteen sutras can be considered.

Bhavartha: Without knowing the difference of self and others, the three types of corrupted Chaitanya manifestation of Agyan  form  i.e. Mithya Darshan-Agyan-Avirati form, he believes ‘ I am anger, I am pride’ etc. Hence the Agyani jiva gets to be Karta of those agyan  form  corrupted Chaitanya manifestations and that agyan form bhava is his karma.  

Tatparya Vritti commentary:  How does the karma get generated due to Agyan, upon asking this, the answer is given in two gathas-

The Upayoga form Atma having characteristics of Upayoga of the forms of Mithya Darshan, Mithya Gyan and Mithya Charitra explicitly, due to lack of own swabhava bhava, engages in False Vikalpa or Mithya Vikalpa. What is the form of vikalpa? ‘I am anger’ etc. form vikalpas are done. Then that jiva gets to be karta of anger etc. upayoga form vikalpa. How is he karta? From  aspect of ashuddha nishchaya naya the Atma Bhava form Jiva is karta of manifestation. This is clarified- In Samanya sense with one kind of bhava in agyan form and in Vishesh form three types of bhavas of Mithya Darshan-Mithya Gyan-Mithya  Charitra, this upayoga form Atma attains bhavas of anger etc. and bhavya-bhavak bhava of  Atma.

What is the meaning of attaining Bhavya-Bhavak Bhava? Bhavya means the Atma manifested in anger form and Bhavak means the inflicting bhava of anger converse to antaratma bhavana. In this way, due to lack of  bheda gyan, without knowing the bheda, corrupting from the nirvikalpa state ‘I am anger’ such vikalpa of atma is generated. And he is  karta of  that anger etc. Upayoga form manifestation from aspect of Ashuddha Nishchaya naya- such is bhavartha. In the same way replacing anger word with pride, deceit, greed, moha, raga, dwesha, karma, nokarma,  mind, speech, body, ears, eyes, smell, taste, touch these sixteen sutras should be considered. In the same way compared to uncorrupted shuddhatma tattva swabhava  the innumerable lok praman vibhava manifestations should also be considered.

Now the same thing is told specially-

Gatha 95:  Three types of this Upayoga engages in vikalpa of ‘I am Dharmastikaya etc.’; therefore that Atma  gets to be karta of his Upayoga form bhava.

Commentary: In reality this Samanya form Agyan which is three types of corrupted Chaitanya manifestations of Mithya darshan-agyan-avirati forms that, without difference of others with own adarshan-agyan-acharitra, hiding all the differences, with gyeya-gyayak bhava experiencing the samanya  base for self and others , ‘I am dharma, I am  Adharma, I am Akash, I am Kaal, I am pudgala, I am other jiva’ such vikalpas are generated. Hence with such delusions of “ I am dharma etc.” – manifesting in such Chaitanya form this Atma gets to be karta of such afflicted Chaitanya manifestation.

Bhavartha: During the vikalpa of dharma etc. without realising own Shuddha Chaitanya form, he becomes one with vikalpa of dharma etc., believing self to be dharma Dravya etc form.

In this way, with agyan Chaitanya manifestation he believes self to be Dharma etc. dravya form, hence agyani jiva is karta of that afflicted Chaitanya manifestation and that agyan bhava is his karma.

Tatparya Vritti Commentary: Now, in spite of being single agyan form in Samanya sense, specifically being three types of Mithya Darshan-Gyan-Charitra forms, such Upayoga form  Atma upon attaining gyeya-gyayak bhava of Atma and other Dravya, does not know the difference due to lack of bheda gyan hence with abheda darshan, abheda gyan and Abheda manifestation ‘I am dharmastikaya’ in this way generates false vikalpa in respect of Atma. Therefore from aspect of ashuddha nishchaya naya in  respect of own  atma devoid of pure atmanubhuti he gets to be karta of jiva manifestation in Mithya Vikalpa form.

Doubt- ‘I am dharmastikaya,’ no body tells like this, then how does it apply? That is clarified-

Answer- ‘ I am Dharmastikaya’ such gyan form vikalpa occurs in mind, that only is called dharmastikaya in Upachar sense. Just as pot shaped vikalpa manifested gyan is called pot, in the same way during contemplation of gyeya tattva ‘this is dharmastikaya’ etc. vikalpa are done by jiva. At that time he does not remember Shuddha atma swabhava. At the time of that vikalpa “I am dharmastikaya” such vikalpa is applicable in Upachar sense- such is bhavartha. Hence it establishes that the agyan of the form of  lack of experience of own shuddhatma only is cause for being karta of karma.

‘Hence the root cause  for  authorship is established to be agyan’ – this is told-

Gatha 96: In this way the Agyani out of Agyan bhava makes other Dravya to be own  form and treats self as other form.

Commentary: In reality like  ‘I am anger’ etc. and ‘I am dharma dravya’  etc., the Atma treats other dravyas as self and treats self also as other Dravya form. Hence this Atma, though he is infinite Shuddha Chaitanya dhatu form free of relations with all substances, even then out of agyan due to corrupted and afflicted Chaitanya manifestations he appears to be karta of own bhava of that kind. In this way like a person afflicted with demon, and a person engaged in  dhyan the root cause of activity  of atma is established to be agyan. This is explained with illustration- Just as a person afflicted with Demon, makes the demon and self as one due to Agyan and engages in non humanly  activities and appears to be karta of those non-humanly acts. In the same way this Atma also out of  agyan makes bhavya-bhavak form others and self as one, therefore the uncorrupted experience alone form Bhavak appears to be karta of improper strange Bhavya form anger etc. corruptions mixed with Chaitanya manifestations.

Just as a with the upadesh of Acharya some simple person contemplates of bull and due to agyan he makes bull and self as one hence ‘I am bull with horns touching the sky’ with  such imagination, he is not able to come out of the door of the house, appearing to be karta of such bhava. In the same way this Atma also due to Agyan treating gyeya-gyayak form others and self as one ‘I am other dravya’ with such imagination appears to be karta of the bhava of the form of subjects of mind in the form of dharma, adharma, akash, kaal, pudgala and other jivas. In the process his own Shuddha Chaitanya substance is afflicted, the gyan gets obscured by the subjects of the senses.

Bhavartha: This Atma out of Agyan, treats the achetan  karma form Bhavak’s  anger etc. Bhavya  as one with Chetan Bhavak. Similarly he believes the corporeal gyeya form Dharma etc. dravyas also to be one with Gyayak. In this way he gets to be karta of corrupted and afflicted Chaitanya manifestations.

Here for explaining the act of believing oneness with anger etc. example of demon afflicted person is given and for explaining the oneness with dharma etc., form other dravyas the example of person engaged in dhyan  is given.

Tatparya Vritti Commentary: In this way as described in earlier two gathas, he manifests in the form of ‘I am  anger’ etc and ‘I am dharmastikaya’ etc. treating anger etc. as his own manifestation form and in the same way makes dharmastikaya etc. Gyeya form other dravyas as Atma form. Who does it? The weak intellect jiva devoid of bheda gyan having  characteristics of Nirvikalpa samadhi, in spite of having Shuddha buddha one natured Atma, he believes self to be as other form and engages his upayoga in raga etc. In what way? With agyan bhava. It establishes that like the example of demon afflicted person in the context of anger etc. and like the example of dhyan immersed person the agyan of the form of lack of Shuddha atma experience is cause for the authorship  of karma.

It is as follows- Just as some demon afflicted person does not realise the difference between atma and demon and   engages in non-humanly acts like lifting rocks etc. kind of surprising activities and gets to be karta of the activities of those nature. In the same way the Jiva also without having bheda gyan having characteristics of Veetrag Param Samayik manifested shuddhopayoga without knowing difference of desire-anger etc.  and shuddhatma he engages in vikalpa of ‘I am anger- I am desire’ etc. and thus gets to be karta of those karmas. This completed the example of the demon afflicted person pertaining to anger etc. In the same way just as some person is engaged in dhyan of huge bull etc. and without knowing the difference of bull and self he engages in atma vikalpa of the forms of ‘I am huge bull, I am Kaamdeva, I am fire, I am nectar like milk stream, I am eagle‘ – this way he gets to be karta of those vikalpas. In the same way the Jiva also with lack of bheda gyan having characteristics of shuddhopayoga manifested in bhavana of equanimity in sukh-dukh, without knowing the difference of shuddhatma and dharma etc. form gyeya substances engages in Atma vikalpa of the form of ‘I am dharmastikaya’ etc. and thus gets to be karta of those vikalpas. Being karta of vikalpa at the same time bandh of Dravya karma accrues. In this way the example of the dhyan engaged person in gyeya substances of dharmastikaya etc. is completed.

Doubt: O Bhagwan! This is dharmastikaya, This is jiva  - If  with such thoughts- vikalpas of gyeya tattvas, it results in karma bandh then it is a waste to contemplate of gyeya tattva, hence one should not think of gyeya tattva?

Answer- It should not be thought so. Although during the period of three gupti form manifested Nirvikalpa Samadhi the contemplation of gyeya tattvas should not be done; even then with the lack of three gupti form manifested dhyan, with shuddhatma being venerable, treating Moksha as venerable in Agam language, during the period of Sarag Samyaktva for avoiding sensual subjects-kashaya etc.  the contemplation of gyeya tattva should be carried out. With that Tattva consideration primarily the punya bandh accrues and traditionally Moksha occurs hence there is no fault. However  at the time of tattva  contemplation  the veetrag gyan of  own experience form manifested shuddhatma is really venerable -this should be known.

Doubt- Why the adjective of Veetrag is strongly applied in the consideration of Veetrag gyan of own  experience? Is the gyan of own experience  sarag form  also?

Answer- The experience of sensory subjects is gyan of own experience in pleasure form well known to all. That is sarag gyan of own experience only. The shuddhatna sukh anubhuti form gyan of own experience is Veetrag. Such narration should be known in the description of gyan of own experience everywhere- such is bhavartha.

Continued….

No comments:

Post a Comment